Measuring recruitment performance helps business aviation operators understand whether their hiring process is fast enough, affordable enough, and producing pilots and crew who perform well over time. The three most useful metrics are time-to-hire, cost-per-hire, and quality of hire.
These metrics should be reviewed together. A fast, inexpensive hire has limited value if the pilot leaves early, fails to meet operational standards, or requires excessive supervision after joining.
Why Recruitment Metrics Matter
Aviation recruitment is different from general hiring. Operators must assess aircraft type ratings, currency, medical certification, insurance requirements, international experience, and operational fit, while also moving quickly in a competitive talent market.
Without measurement, flight departments may assume their recruitment process is working because positions are eventually filled. Metrics reveal whether the process is efficient, whether costs are controlled, and whether new hires are actually contributing to safe and reliable operations.
Time-to-Hire: Measuring Process Speed
Time-to-hire measures how quickly a candidate moves through the hiring process once they enter the pipeline. It is calculated from the date the candidate applies or is sourced to the date they accept the offer.
Formula:
Time-to-Hire = Offer acceptance date – Candidate pipeline entry date
This metric shows how efficient the interview, evaluation, approval, and offer stages are. A long time-to-hire may indicate slow internal approvals, too many interview stages, delayed background checks, or poor communication with candidates.
It is different from time-to-fill, which starts when the requisition is approved and includes sourcing time before a candidate applies. Time-to-fill is therefore usually equal to or longer than time-to-hire.
Time-to-Fill: Measuring Overall Vacancy Duration
Time-to-fill measures the total time a role remains open, from requisition approval to offer acceptance. It includes job posting, sourcing, screening, interviews, decision-making, and offer acceptance.
Formula:
Time-to-Fill = Offer acceptance date – Requisition open date
For aviation operators, time-to-fill is especially important for type-rated pilot roles, maintenance technicians, and specialized operational positions. A long vacancy can affect aircraft availability, trip scheduling, training plans, and crew workload.
SHRM’s 2026 benchmarking data reports a median time-to-fill of 39 calendar days for nonexecutive roles, although aviation roles with specific type ratings or regulatory requirements may take longer.
Cost-per-Hire: Measuring Recruitment Efficiency
Cost-per-hire measures the average cost of making one hire. It includes both internal and external recruitment costs divided by the number of hires.
Formula:
Cost-per-Hire = (Internal recruiting costs + External recruiting costs) / Total number of hires
Internal costs may include recruiter salaries, interview time, training, and administrative resources. External costs may include job advertising, recruitment agency fees, background checks, assessment tools, travel, and relocation support.
For aviation operators, cost-per-hire should be reviewed alongside the cost of leaving a position unfilled. A delayed pilot hire can lead to canceled trips, contract crew expenses, overtime, and reduced aircraft utilization.

Quality of Hire: Measuring Long-Term Value
Quality of hire measures whether a new hire performs well, fits the operation, and remains with the company. It is widely considered the most important recruitment metric, but also one of the most difficult to measure.
A practical quality-of-hire score can combine:
- Hiring manager satisfaction at 90 days.
- Performance review results at six or 12 months.
- Retention at six and 12 months.
- Training completion and time to operational readiness.
- Safety and compliance performance.
- Feedback from supervisors, peers, and clients.
One common approach averages hiring manager ratings, performance ratings, and 12-month retention into a single score.
For pilots, quality of hire should also include type-rating currency, recurrent training performance, crew resource management skills, and adherence to standard operating procedures.
How to Use the Metrics Together
Each metric answers a different question:
| Metric | What it measures | Key question |
| Time-to-hire | Candidate pipeline speed | How quickly do qualified candidates move through the process? |
| Time-to-fill | Total vacancy duration | How long does it take to fill a role from approval to acceptance? |
| Cost-per-hire | Recruitment spend per hire | Is the hiring process financially efficient? |
| Quality of hire | New-hire performance and retention | Are we hiring people who succeed and stay? |
A strong aviation recruitment program balances all three. Reducing time-to-hire should not come at the expense of compliance, safety culture, or long-term retention.
Additional Metrics Worth Tracking
Alongside the core metrics, operators can track:
- Offer acceptance rate.
- Source of hire, such as referrals, job boards, agencies, or direct outreach.
- Applicant-to-interview ratio.
- Interview-to-offer ratio.
- 90-day and one-year retention.
- Candidate experience or candidate Net Promoter Score.
- Time to operational readiness after hire.
These additional measures help identify whether delays occur in sourcing, screening, interviews, offers, or onboarding.
Build a Simple Recruitment Dashboard
A practical dashboard should be reviewed monthly or quarterly by flight department leadership. It should include metrics by role, aircraft type, location, and recruitment source.
For each role, track:
- Date requisition opened.
- Date candidate entered the pipeline.
- Date offer was accepted.
- Total recruitment cost.
- Recruitment source.
- Training completion date.
- 90-day and 12-month retention.
- Hiring manager and operational performance feedback.
This allows the operator to identify bottlenecks and improve future hiring decisions.
How FCI Helps
Flight Crew International (FCI) supports aviation operators with recruitment, contract pilots, and crew leasing solutions. With more than 20 years of aviation recruitment and crew leasing experience, FCI focuses on promptly filling aviation roles for clients worldwide.
Operators can use FCI’s recruitment support to improve access to qualified candidates, reduce time-to-fill for specialized roles, and maintain a reliable pipeline of aviation professionals. Learn more through FCI’s contract pilot services or submit a staffing request through the FCI contact page.
How Crewlocator Helps
Crewlocator helps operators identify available aviation professionals based on location and availability. This can reduce sourcing time and support faster shortlist creation for contract or permanent roles.
The platform is also available on Android and iOS. Operators should still complete their own qualification, currency, and compliance review before assigning a candidate.
Conclusion
Aviation recruitment performance should be measured through a combination of speed, cost, and quality. Time-to-hire and time-to-fill show process efficiency, cost-per-hire shows financial efficiency, and quality of hire shows whether the recruitment process is producing long-term value.
By tracking these metrics consistently, business aviation operators can make better hiring decisions, reduce operational disruption, and build a more stable and capable flight department.
FAQs
What is time-to-hire?
It is the number of days from when a candidate enters the recruitment pipeline to when they accept the offer.
What is the difference between time-to-hire and time-to-fill?
Time-to-hire starts when a candidate enters the pipeline, while time-to-fill starts when the requisition opens and includes sourcing time.
How is cost-per-hire calculated?
Divide total internal and external recruitment costs by the number of hires.
What is the quality of hire?
It measures a new hire’s performance, operational fit, retention, and long-term contribution to the organization.
Why is quality of hire important in aviation?
Aviation roles require technical qualifications, safety awareness, and operational fit, so long-term performance matters as much as hiring speed.
Should operators prioritize speed over quality?
No. The goal is the shortest hiring time that still protects candidate quality, compliance, and retention.
How does Crewlocator support recruitment performance?
Crewlocator helps operators identify available candidates based on location and availability, which can reduce sourcing time and improve pipeline visibility.